St Helens 16–19 Leeds Rhinos — Qualifying Semi-Final, 2005 Super League Finals Series

30 Sep 2005 · Knowsley Road, St Helens · Attendance: 13,209

Data last verified: 11 August 2026.

Qualifying Semi-Final, 2005 Super League finals series: St Helens 16–19 Leeds Rhinos, at Knowsley Road, St Helens on 30 Sep 2005.

Sourcing caveat: St Helens' two listed Jamie Lyon tries plus two goals total 12 points, four short of their actual 16 — confirmed this is a gap in Rugby League Project's own scoresheet for this match (its own table lists only Lyon's double), not a transcription error on this site's part; a further St Helens try-scorer is required by the arithmetic but wasn't identified in any source checked; reported as an unresolved gap rather than an invented name. Both lineups fetched cleanly with real, varied squad numbers on the first attempt, with no suspicious sequential 1-13 index, so no re-fetch was needed. James Roby's number, 21, and his slot at Halfback rather than his later, far more familiar Hooker berth, stood out as unusual for a player who became one of the era's outstanding hookers — plausible for a 19-year-old squad player rotating through a utility-back role early in his career (with Keiron Cunningham established as St Helens' regular Hooker at 9), and the same number/role recurs consistently on the same source page, so it is accepted as printed. Leeds' lineup here cross-matched exactly, unchanged, across both further 2005 finals appearances involving the club (Elimination Final was not a Leeds fixture, but the Grand Final v Bradford), giving strong confidence. Coaches confirmed via web search: Daniel Anderson (St Helens — Wikipedia's biography confirms he was appointed in 2005 succeeding Ian Millward, with an ABC News report dated 18 May 2005 fixing the appointment well before this September match, and that he remained in post through the end of 2008, consistent with 13ax's already-established 2008 sourcing) and Tony Smith (Leeds — already established by 13ay as having held the role from November 2003 to October 2007, fully covering this September 2005 match).

Scorers

St HelensTries: Lyon (2)
Goals: Lyon (2/3 conversions)
Leeds RhinosTries: Lauitiiti; McGuire; Ward
Goals: Sinfield (3/3 conversions)
Drop goals: Sinfield

Team sheets

St HelensLeeds Rhinos
1Paul WellensFullbackRichard Mathers1
20Ian HardmanWingMark Calderwood2
3Jamie LyonCentreChev Walker3
4Willie TalauCentreChris McKenna12
2Ade GardnerWingMarcus Bai5
6Jason HooperFive-EighthDanny McGuire6
21James RobyHalfbackRob Burrow7
8Nick FozzardPropRyan Bailey8
9Keiron CunninghamHookerAndrew Dunemann14
17Paul AndersonPropDanny Ward15
11Lee GilmourSecond RowWillie Poching16
15Mike BennettSecond RowGareth Ellis20
12Jon WilkinLockKevin Sinfield13
Substitutes
14Mick HighamMatt Diskin9
19James GrahamJamie Jones-Buchanan18
24Maurie Fa'asavaluAli Lauiti'iti11
27Vinnie AndersonBarrie McDermott10
Daniel AndersonCoachTony Smith

Match officials

RefereeAshley Klein

Match report

Leeds Rhinos beat St Helens 19-16 at Knowsley Road on 30 September 2005 in a Super League Qualifying Semi-Final, leading 12-0 at half-time before holding on as Saints rallied. A Kevin Sinfield field goal proved decisive, sending Leeds directly through to the Grand Final and dropping League Leaders' Shield winners St Helens into the Elimination Final.

Sources

← 2005 Super League Season — ladder & full finals series