Leeds 7-7 (drawn; replay 26-12) Hull FC — 1909/10 Challenge Cup Final

Fartown, Huddersfield (both legs) · Attendance: 19,413 (drawn game) / 11,608 (replay)

Data last verified: 11 August 2026.

1909/10 Challenge Cup Final: Leeds 7-7 (drawn; replay 26-12) Hull FC, at Fartown, Huddersfield (both legs).

Sourcing caveat: Referee not identified for either the drawn game or the replay. Full line-ups for both games (added on a fourth research pass) were located on the Wikipedia article already cited above; the lineups below are for the replay, the match that actually decided the Cup — a handful of positions changed between the drawn game and the replay (Hull started Harry Taylor at fullback and Ned Rogers on the wing in the drawn game, versus E. Rogers at fullback and Ernest Atkinson on the wing in the replay; Leeds' J. Fawcett moved from wing to half-back for the replay, with Harold Rowe, Billy Ward and S. Whittaker also appearing among personnel changes), which is not reflected below. Neither source individually labels player positions; the groupings below (fullback; four three-quarters; two half-backs; six forwards) follow the standard-for-the-era listing order, except centre Jim Devereux, independently confirmed at that position by his own Wikipedia biography (used in an earlier pass), which matches his slot in this table.

Scorers

LeedsTries: Walter Goldthorpe (drawn game); Harold Rowe (replay); Walter Goldthorpe (replay); Fred Webster (replay); Harry Topham (replay)
Goals: Frank Young (2 goals, drawn game); Frank Young (7 goals, replay)
Hull FCTries: George Cottrell (drawn game); George Connell (replay); Harry Walton (replay)
Goals: Ned Rogers (2 goals, drawn game); Ned Rogers (3 goals, replay)

Teams

LeedsHull FC
Frank YoungFullbackE. Rogers
Harold RoweThree-quarterG. T. Cottrell
Walter GoldthorpeThree-quarterJim Devereux
C. GillieThree-quarterAndy Morton
F. BarronThree-quarterErnest Atkinson
E. WareHalf-backNed Rogers
J. FawcettHalf-backHarry Wallace
Fred WebsterForwardTom Herridge
Fred HarrisonForwardWill Osborne
Harry TophamForwardDick Taylor
Billy WardForwardWilliam Holder
Billy JarmanForwardG. Connell
S. WhittakerForwardH. Walton

Match officials

Referee—

Match report

This was rugby league's first-ever drawn Challenge Cup Final: Leeds and Hull FC finished 7-7 at Fartown, Huddersfield on 16 April 1910, with Hull leading 7-2 at half-time on George Cottrell's try before Walter Goldthorpe's try and a Frank Young goal levelled it late on; Ned Rogers had a last-gasp try claim controversially denied for Hull. In the replay two days later at the same venue, Leeds took full control, racing to a 16-0 half-time lead and winning 26-12 with four tries (Harold Rowe, Walter Goldthorpe, Fred Webster, Harry Topham) and seven goals from Frank Young, while Hull, missing several key players including the injured Stanley Britton, mounted only a late rally through George Connell and Harry Walton. It was Leeds' first Challenge Cup win in their first final appearance, while Hull suffered a third consecutive final defeat. The Rugby League Challenge Cup is rugby league's oldest and most prestigious knockout competition, first contested in 1896/97 under what was then the Northern Union. Its history has been interrupted only by the two World Wars, with four editions lost between 1915/16 and 1918/19 and one more in 1939/40; the finals played either side of those gaps, and during the Second World War itself, were sometimes contested as regional or two-legged fixtures under wartime emergency arrangements rather than the usual single showpiece match. For much of the competition's early history the final rotated around northern club and representative grounds such as Headingley, Fartown, Central Park and the Athletic Ground, Rochdale, before Wembley Stadium became the final's permanent home from 1928/29 onward (with a short break during Wembley's 2000-2007 reconstruction, when finals were staged at Murrayfield, Twickenham and the Millennium Stadium instead). This was the 14th Challenge Cup final played, and, under the name “Leeds,” the 1st Challenge Cup title for the club.

Round by round

Round 1

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Barrow 0–15 St HelensCavendish Park—26 Feb 1910
Bramley 3–3 Rochdale HornetsBarley Mow—26 Feb 1910
Dewsbury 3–8 Wakefield TrinityCrown Flatt—26 Feb 1910
Hull KR 3–5 LeedsCraven Street—26 Feb 1910
Hull FC 10–7 LeighThe Boulevard—26 Feb 1910
Keighley 5–0 Broughton RangersLawkholme Lane—26 Feb 1910
Merthyr 7–12 Ebbw ValeCollege Field—26 Feb 1910
Millom 9–4 Brookland RoversSalthouse—26 Feb 1910
Oldham 0–2 HuddersfieldWatersheddings—26 Feb 1910
Purston Tigers 10–23 Halifax——26 Feb 1910
Runcorn 9–4 Bradford NorthernCanal Street—26 Feb 1910
Salford 64–0 York IrishWeaste Ground—26 Feb 1910
Warrington 31–3 Wigan HighfieldWilderspool—26 Feb 1910
Widnes 0–6 HunsletLowerhouse Lane—26 Feb 1910
Wigan 16–5 SwintonCentral Park—26 Feb 1910
York 0–0 BatleyWigginton Road—26 Feb 1910

Round 1 Replay

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Batley 3–3 YorkMount Pleasant—1 Mar 1910
Rochdale Hornets 11–5 BramleyAthletic Ground, Rochdale—1 Mar 1910
Batley 8–0 YorkThe Boulevard (neutral)—3 Mar 1910

Round 2

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Batley 0–8 Hull FCMount Pleasant—12 Mar 1910
Halifax 21–6 St HelensThrum Hall—12 Mar 1910
Huddersfield 3–8 Ebbw ValeFartown—12 Mar 1910
Hunslet 2–2 Wakefield TrinityParkside—12 Mar 1910
Leeds 13–3 Rochdale HornetsHeadingley—12 Mar 1910
Runcorn 3–5 KeighleyCanal Street—12 Mar 1910
Salford 12–5 WiganWeaste Ground—12 Mar 1910
Warrington 37–0 MillomWilderspool—12 Mar 1910

Round 2 Replay

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Wakefield Trinity 2–5 HunsletBelle Vue—16 Mar 1910

Round 3

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Hull FC 13–7 HalifaxThe Boulevard—19 Mar 1910
Keighley 4–7 LeedsLawkholme Lane—19 Mar 1910
Salford 8–2 Ebbw ValeWeaste Ground—19 Mar 1910
Warrington 7–0 HunsletWilderspool—19 Mar 1910

Semi Final

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Hull FC 20–6 SalfordBelle Vue, Halifax11,0002 Apr 1910
Warrington 10–11 LeedsWheater's Field, Broughton14,9592 Apr 1910

Final

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Leeds 7–7 Hull FCFartown, Huddersfield19,41316 Apr 1910

Final Replay

ResultVenueAttendanceDate
Leeds 26–12 Hull FCFartown, Huddersfield11,60818 Apr 1910

Early rounds feature amateur and community clubs alongside professional ones; team names are linked only where this site has a team page for that exact club, matching the same safety-first approach used for the Final's own results table.

Sources

← All Challenge Cup Finals