Warrington 4-4 (drawn; replay 8-4) Halifax — 1953/54 Challenge Cup Final

Wembley Stadium, London / Odsal, Bradford · Attendance: 81,841 (drawn game) / 102,569 (replay, with some estimates suggesting an actual crowd nearer 120,000)

Data last verified: 11 August 2026.

1953/54 Challenge Cup Final: Warrington 4-4 (drawn; replay 8-4) Halifax, at Wembley Stadium, London / Odsal, Bradford.

Sourcing caveat: Halifax's individual penalty-goal kicker in the drawn game is not confirmed by name; it is unclear whether referee Ron Gelder took charge of the drawn game, the replay, or both. The lineups below are for the replay only (the match that decided the Cup) — no separate team-sheet was found for the drawn game, and it is not confirmed whether either side made changes between the two matches. The Wikipedia source gives positions rather than printed squad numbers, so numbers here are inferred from the standard 1-13 positional order used throughout this era.

Scorers

Warrington	Goals: Harry Bath (2 penalty goals, drawn match)
Halifax	Goals: Halifax kicker unconfirmed by name (2 penalty goals, drawn match)

Teams

Warrington			Halifax
1	Eric Frodsham	Fullback	Tyssul Griffiths	1
2	Brian Bevan	Wing	Arthur Daniels	2
3	Jim Challinor	Centre	Tommy Lynch	3
4	Ron Ryder	Centre	Billy Mather	4
5	Stan McCormick	Wing	Dai Royston Bevan	5
6	Ray Price	Stand-off	Ken Dean	6
7	Gerry Helme	Scrum-half	Stan Kielty	7
8	Danny Naughton	Prop	John Thorley	8
9	Frank Wright	Hooker	Alvin Ackerley	9
10	Gerry Lowe	Prop	Jack Wilkinson	10
11	Harry Bath	Second row	Albert Fearnley	11
12	Austin Heathwood	Second row	Derrick Schofield	12
13	Bob Ryan	Loose forward	Des Clarkson	13

Match officials

Referee	Ron Gelder
Lance Todd Trophy	Gerry Helme (Warrington) — Lance Todd Trophy; became the first player to win it twice

Match report

Warrington and Halifax, who had finished first and second in the league table, drew 4-4 at Wembley Stadium on 24 April 1954 in front of 81,841 — a match in which no try was scored, the scoring coming entirely from two penalty goals apiece (Harry Bath for Warrington). The replay was held at Odsal Stadium, Bradford on 5 May 1954 and drew an official crowd of 102,569, where Warrington won 8-4 through tries from Jim Challinor and Gerry Helme, with Harry Bath again among the goal-kickers and Tyssul Griffiths kicking for Halifax. Halifax had three tries disallowed across the two matches. Gerry Helme's Lance Todd Trophy win made him the first player to claim the award twice. For much of the competition's early history the final rotated around northern club and representative grounds such as Headingley, Fartown, Central Park and the Athletic Ground, Rochdale, before Wembley Stadium became the final's permanent home from 1928/29 onward (with a short break during Wembley's 2000-2007 reconstruction, when finals were staged at Murrayfield, Twickenham and the Millennium Stadium instead). Since 1946/47, the competition's individual award, the Lance Todd Trophy, has been presented to the final's outstanding player, voted for by a panel of media representatives at the final whistle — on several notable occasions the trophy has gone to a player on the losing side, an unusual honour that reflects the award's focus on individual performance rather than simply reflecting the final scoreline. This was the 53rd Challenge Cup final played, and, under the name “Warrington,” the 4th Challenge Cup title for the club.

Round by round

Jump to round:

Round 1

Result	Venue	Attendance	Date
Halifax 19–0 Dewsbury	Thrum Hall	—	6 February 1954
Hull 24–0 Widnes	The Boulevard	—	6 February 1954
Keighley 12–11 Barrow	Lawkholme Lane	—	6 February 1954
Latchford Albion 20–40 Wigan	Wilderspool	—	6 February 1954
Leeds 13–20 Batley	Headingley	—	6 February 1954
Liverpool City 5–15 Oldham	Knotty Ash	—	6 February 1954
Wakefield Trinity 24–13 Whitehaven	Belle Vue (Wakefield)	—	6 February 1954
York 18–0 Hull Kingston Rovers	Wigginton Road	—	6 February 1954
Barrow 6–10 Keighley	Craven Park (Barrow)	—	13 February 1954
Batley 6–23 Leeds	Mount Pleasant	—	13 February 1954
Castleford 8–5 Doncaster	Wheldon Road	—	13 February 1954
Leigh 13–4 Swinton	Kirkhall Lane	—	13 February 1954
Oldham 18–11 Liverpool City	Watersheddings	—	13 February 1954
Rochdale Hornets 9–9 Bradford Northern	Athletic Grounds (Rochdale)	—	13 February 1954
St Helens 26–7 Featherstone Rovers	Knowsley Road	—	13 February 1954
Warrington 17–0 Bramley	Wilderspool	—	13 February 1954
Wheldale 6–32 Workington Town	Wheldon Road	—	13 February 1954
Whitehaven 15–3 Wakefield Trinity	Recreation Ground (Whitehaven)	—	13 February 1954
Widnes 2–5 Hull	Naughton Park	—	13 February 1954
Wigan 41–2 Latchford Albion	Central Park	—	13 February 1954
Belle Vue Rangers 15–20 Huddersfield	Belle Vue (Wakefield)	—	15 February 1954
Dewsbury 9–15 Halifax	Crown Flatt	—	16 February 1954
Bradford Northern 11–2 Rochdale Hornets	Odsal Stadium	—	17 February 1954
Bramley 5–30 Warrington	Barley Mow	—	17 February 1954
Featherstone Rovers 16–27 St Helens	Post Office Road	—	17 February 1954
Huddersfield 31–6 Belle Vue Rangers	Fartown	—	17 February 1954
Hunslet 20–5 Salford	Parkside	—	17 February 1954
Swinton 2–17 Leigh	Station Road	—	17 February 1954
Workington Town 50–2 Wheldale	Borough Park	—	17 February 1954
Doncaster 7–2 Castleford	Bentley Road Stadium	—	18 February 1954
Hull Kingston Rovers 0–0 York	Craven Park (Hull, Old)	—	18 February 1954
Salford 3–18 Hunslet	The Willows	—	22 February 1954

Round 2

Result	Venue	Attendance	Date
Halifax 24–5 Keighley	Thrum Hall	—	6 March 1954
Huddersfield 12–5 St Helens	Fartown	—	6 March 1954
Hull 5–5 Workington Town	The Boulevard	—	6 March 1954
Hunslet 10–2 Whitehaven	Parkside	—	6 March 1954
Leeds 12–3 Leigh	Headingley	—	6 March 1954
Oldham 4–7 Warrington	Watersheddings	—	6 March 1954
Wigan 15–10 Bradford Northern	Central Park	—	6 March 1954
York 11–2 Doncaster	Wigginton Road	—	6 March 1954
Workington Town 17–14 Hull	Borough Park	—	11 March 1954

Round 3

Result	Venue	Attendance	Date
Hunslet 16–7 Huddersfield	Parkside	—	20 March 1954
Leeds 31–11 Workington Town	Headingley	—	20 March 1954
Warrington 26–5 York	Wilderspool	—	20 March 1954
Wigan 0–2 Halifax	Central Park	—	20 March 1954

Semi Final

Result	Venue	Attendance	Date
Halifax 18–3 Hunslet	Odsal Stadium, Bradford	46,961	3 April 1954
Warrington 8–4 Leeds	Station Road, Swinton	37,249	3 April 1954

Final

Result	Venue	Attendance	Date
Warrington 4–4 Halifax	Wembley Stadium, London	81,841	24 April 1954

Final Replay

Result	Venue	Attendance	Date
Warrington 8–4 Halifax	Odsal Stadium, Bradford	102,569	5 May 1954

Early rounds feature amateur and community clubs alongside professional ones; team names are linked only where this site has a team page for that exact club, matching the same safety-first approach used for the Final's own results table.

Sources

← All Challenge Cup Finals